Women’s Sexual Desire, Antidepressants, and Viagra: Can We All Get Along?
Wednesday, July 23rd, 2008Today the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA) published research that suggests women who experience sexual side effects from the use of antidepressants may obtain relief by taking sildenafil (Viagra).
For the thousands of women who take antidepressants, decreased sexual desire is a huge problem. The Women’s Sexual Health Foundation, of which I am editor of the organization’s Women’s Sexual Health Journal, has been surveying the problem through an on-going internet poll.
All of this information is sure to cause a huge buzz among those of us who treat women with sexual problems. On one side will be feminists like Dr. Leonore Tiefer, who argue that women’s sexual problems cannot be treated with a pill. On the other, physicians who genuinely want to help their female patients with, well, a pill.
Having worked in medical settings and in my private practice with women (and men) who experience sexual side effects from antidepressants, I don’t think the answer lies in entire answer lies in the use of a pill, either. I think it lies in the way in which we treat depression, and the way in which we understand women.
This is a big, complicated topic, too big, perhaps, for a blog. But doctors tend to hand out antidepressants like Pez, medicating situations that need and deserve to be explored in therapy. So that’s the first problem right there. Some people absolutely need medication. But all people in that group also need psychotherapy. And then there are those who do get tripped up by life–perhaps a job loss, or the traumatic death of a loved one. If they have trouble climbing out of a dark mood after a few months, then they may also benefit from medication–and psychotherapy.
The largest group by far, those with mild depression clouded by longstanding automatic negative thoughts (”ANTS”) can be helped with psychotherapy alone. This group, however, often receives Pez instead, with the belief that it’s just easier. Given the potential sexual and other side effects, it’s quite clear that it’s not that easy at all.
The fact is, too often it is physicians–GP’s–who are prescribing medication. Psychological issues are often much deeper than lay people–including, dare I say it, physicians–realize. In my ideal world (never gonna happen, but you can view it anyway), all folks who visit the physician for an antidepressant would get a recommendation to have an evaluation by a mental health professional. Going further, they would all be required (definitely never gonna happen) to have 6-12 sessions of cognitive behavioral therapy.
But remember I said that it’s complicated? Well, of the women who go on antidepressants and have sexual side effects, how many of them do you suppose had pre-existing sexual concerns? You don’t know, do you? Well, neither do I. But I’m guessing it’s a large number. And who knows, maybe some number of women are going on antidepressants because they cannot have an orgasm, or are inhibited, or were sexually abused and cannot enjoy sex. I know I recently treated a woman who had been treated for deep depression who realized that part of the reason she was so depressed is because she couldn’t have an orgasm. Think about that–never experiencing something that comes naturally, like being able to laugh or cry. I wonder if anyone–physician or psychologist–had ever asked her about sexual function.
So we could go in all kinds of directions with the thoughts generated by this one small study. I’d love to hear what you think–I invite you to comment, and I’ll write more on this topic, based on my own ponderings as well as any comments I receive.
